by Frau_Blucher » Sat Oct 01, 2005 3:47 pm
Ditto pretty much what Marv said...
British Sea Power: an excellent albeit short set given the festival setting. Blasted out of the gates as usual with "It Ended on an Oily Stage" and finishing with their rousing "Lately/Rock in A" sendoff combo...although "Rock in A" was distinctly different somehow. I thought I saw a lot of the younger crowd get wowed by their energetic performance. However, I'm kinda resigned to them never making it really big - they're almost too lyrical and melodic for today's mass consumption. There's no way I'm missing them this winter on their club tour - they're fabulous in an intimate setting.
Interpol: much better than what I saw of them in the Glastonbury webcast. Much more stage presence, energy, and animation. A very excellent show. These guys are extremely polished for what is still a very young band. If BSP have the lyrical and spiritual heart of Joy Division, Interpol are the driving and intense musical heirs.
NY Dolls: I thought I'd tire of them after the novelty of a couple of songs, but like Marvy said, they maintained the energy and presence to keep me interested. "Looking For a Kiss" was a classic kickoff. "Personality Crisis" held together the middle of the set while "Trash" and "Jet Boy" rocked the house at the end. I heard a lot of cynical comment by the younger crowd, but by the end, a lot of them were rocking and dance. It's ironic how polished David Johansen and Sylvain Sylvain's stage presences were considering the knock that they hardly knew what the hell they were doing in their early days. They crushed the Killers as far as stage presence went.
The Killers: they did some really good songs but kinda thudded. Brandon Flowers' vocals just got lost in the mix. The opening "Jenny Was a Friend of Mine" was preceded by a piped-in vocal version of "A Love Story" theme - pretty cool actually, very theatric. But "Mr. Brightside", "Smile Like You Mean It" and Somebody Told Me" were sprinkled amongst an otherwise unmemorable set - they need more good songs to headline such a festival. My favorite "All These Things That I've Done" was saved for the encore so we waited to the bitter end. But it was essentially ruined by a BORING lead-in of some repetitive song that I can't remember plus an unnecessary cover of a Bowie track off Ziggy Stardust. The overriding impression I have is that these guys are lightweights and they have some work cut out for their next release. It pisses me off that they've sold over a million records vs BSP's 100,000, but I guess their cookie-cutter, cut-n-dry digestable music is an A&R man's wet dream, kinda ala Coldplay.
Overall, supremely worthwhile, especially with the backdrop of Manhattan behind the stage and the orange twilight giving way to a magnificent city nightscape. I wish more of you were there.