by Frau_Blucher » Wed Mar 23, 2011 1:38 pm
When I looked at this SXSW schedule, I knew that I'd miss more "good" bands than at any other South-By ever. It was loaded with "good"…sometimes really good. Yet I didn't see anything new that I had a good feeling would jump out at me as "great" (as has happened in other years). It pretty much played out that way. No new band totally floored me, and I'm a little disappointed in that. The great stuff was stuff I knew would be great - Joy Formidable, Yuck, OMD, etc. There was also a huge number of bands that were described with some mention of "sounds like" or "influenced by" [insert] "Sonic Youth", "Dinosaur Jr" and/or "My Bloody Valentine". Many of those were entertaining, but none were as inventive as the early 2000s indie rock resurgence that used our beloved New Wave as a foundation. There are no giants of the shoegaze revival yet, as much as I was looking. Still the best time I've ever had at a South-By and many more “A" ratings than any other year. Said ratings and some pics below (mostly mine but not all):
[b]A+: The Joy Formidable @ Buffalo Billiards[/b] - This was not just the gig of this SXSW. It was likely THE gig of any gig I've seen at ANY South-By. It may have been the best gig I've seen in the last 20 years. Absolutely mental audience that had many of us pogo'ing and fist-pumping throughout the set. I was deliriously jacked up. TJF are like a drug. You get a BIG rush from their gigs. You end up wanting more. I saw them three other times, but this was the best. TJF may have outstripped BSP as my favorite band. Maybe. Shit, I don't know! Someone else’s video of our arms flailing about in the pit:
<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="640" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/lAKgTXqv2mo" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
[b]A: O.M.D. @ Stubb's[/b] - An abbreviated set because of the camera crane accident. This took nothing away from the gig for me. All the great things that we heard from the New York and other shows apply here. Electrying! (ahem). The shortened time meant they played none of the new songs (I think) - only the classics. Come on, do we really give a shit about the new songs? Deep down?? Closing 1-2 of "Enola Gay" and "Electricity" is something I thought I'd never see again. Not my pic:
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646150_eYjSt-X3.jpg">
[b]A: The Joy Formidable @ The Parish[/b] - This was the first of four TJF shows I saw and the shortest, but they brought it! I felt like my SXSW really started when these guys finally played. They've got the alt-pop-rock formula freaking DOWN. Most people in line that I chatted with were waiting for Antlers. Dropped jaws and high-fives from the uninitiated are a pretty good sign that they made a great first impression. I can't think of any band out there that can bring it like they can on these short festival sets.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646035_kTni8-X3.jpg">#8232;
[b]A: Yuck @ Flamingo Cantina[/b] - The best of three Yuck performances I saw. They are totally Dinosaur Jr. I don't care. I love it. I won't play the "they're copying so-and-so" card. That's only useful if things are copied poorly or a band is unentertaining. Yuck are very entertaining. Yes, some of their songs also sound a bit too self-similar. I'm sure New Order lost a lot of sleep on that one too. I do hope they improve in all these areas, but for now, a really fun band.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645832_SDVDJ-X3.jpg">
[b]A: The Joy Formidable @ Mellow Johnny's[/b] - A really intimate affair at Lance Armstrong's bike shop for KEXP day party. KEXP seem to like them quite a lot, as it seems anyone who has encountered them live does. It felt like watching them at a private party, and that was pretty special. Not a mental crowd or anything, but just a great, straight, driving set. Like a drug fix, leaving you wanting more.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646067_qUhXE-X3.jpg">
[b]A: Kid Canaveral @ Maggie Mae's[/b] - They were on my radar, but I had a pretty pointed sense that they weren't really "my kind of music". Seeing them live, I have to ask myself "Why the hell not?" Great tunes. Great engagement. Perhaps indie pop with a Celtic flair. I'm kinda digging the bevy of recent bands not trying to hide their heavy Scottish accents - Canaveral, Phantom Band, Glasvegas, etc.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646303_aJV58-X3.jpg">
[b]A: The Joy Formidable @ Brush Square Park[/b] - This might have been their weakest (relative!) set given the tent setting. Still, Neak, their sound guy, does wonders even with a portable PA setup. Vocals came out the best amongst all the gigs actually. Might have been an A- except for the highlight of Ritzy demolishing a Miley Cyrus guitar piñata that she and the band spotted at a shop - an awesome take-off on the classic rock meme. Awful vid except for the smashing ~1:40 in:
<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="640" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/Cv74-ztSOmI" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
[b]A-: Sharon Van Etten @ Mohawk Patio[/b] - Van Etten charmed the shit out of me (not literally of course…well maybe a bit). She's "just" another indie-folk-pop singer-songwriter, but she's got such a great voice and charm. A sweet desperation in her voice. I was really bummed not to have caught her again at Central Presbyterian Church - perfect venue for her. Not even my kind of music, but she's one of those artists who transcends genre barriers and will hopefully grab fans from all around.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645916_N8fb3-X3.jpg">
[b]A-: Twin Shadow @ Mohawk Patio[/b] - A LOT better than I was expecting. Their main video looks a bit one-dimensional, but live, they are a fully fleshed out, truly new wave band with all the hooks, melody and perfect keyboards and guitar interplay you'd expect from new wave. A very pleasant surprise.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645991_o2z6b-X3.jpg">
[b]A-: Yuck @ Club deVille[/b] - The first of three times I saw Yuck, and a revelation. Yes, they had the "lo-fi", "psychedelic" and "showgaze revival" labels and worse - even "mimic's Dinosaur Jr". Again, I don't care. They are really freaking excellent and entertaining. Their lead guitarist is a virtuoso - I could watch nothing but him all day. Why the minus? The Asian chick bugged me for some reason. That's all.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645844_2V28E-X3.jpg">
[b]A-: Friendly Fires @ Windish Agency House[/b] - it's the early 90s all over again with more pulsey disco in it than the more indie-oriented "electroclash" bands of the early 2000s. Imagine a young, unassuming London financier type walking onto stage and then just ripping it up on both the keyboards and with his dance moves. Not really my thing but super infectious. The audience was massively pumped. If you remotely like this sort of thing, keep an eye out for them.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646355_QGxkR-X3.jpg">
[b]B+: Yuck @ Stubbs[/b] - A possible chink in Yuck's armor is that they're not very engaging personality-wise on stage. It doesn't show so much in a small venue because their little bits of wry humor come out well there. There's no sense of that at all on a larger stage. They would do well to develop some more interactivity, but then again, Joy Division and a lot of other folks never had that either…but then again then again, they're not Joy Division.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645802_DafsP-X3.jpg">
[b]B+: Violens @ Flamingo Cantina[/b] - I've loved the odd Violens track and disliked many others. Usually the latter are when they sound too much like their NYC brethren Vampire Weekend. Fuckinhell, the dreaded Vampire Weekend and all their whitey-fied Afro-Garfunkel twee spawn! But…I was also told that they rock out a lot more live than on their albums. This was indeed true. They are very worth going to see. Why they don't marry more of their live sound to the albums? No fucking idea.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645897_PxZ4k-X3.jpg">
[b]B+: The Calm Blue Sea @ Skinny's Ballroom[/b] - These guys were probably the epitome of the swirly, trippy guitar sound I was looking for throughout much of this SXSW. At one point in this set, my buddy Greg noticed what I was doing too - "Dude, wait, you're totally on an experimental rock trip right now, aren't you?" I guess so. They fit the bill…mostly. They didn't WOW me. It was cool It was a trip. But not the total revelation that I was hoping for.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646499_AUdbZ-X3.jpg">
[b]B+: Admiral Fallow @ Maggie Mae's[/b] - Again, not really my kind of music (I keep saying that), but they're very very good at what they do and immensely engaging in a small venue. Think of sprinkles of Elbow and Frightened Rabbit with more folkish Celtic flair. If this sounds attractive at all, it might be worth sampling some tracks.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646691_oBGef-X3.jpg">
[b]B: Ume @ Skinny's Ballroom[/b] - I rated Ume very highly last year. They've done nothing more for themselves since. Lauren seems to like to just jam…HARD. She leaves little space in her songs for swells and releases and some melody, but I think that's where they're at their best, like on "The Conductor". They have plenty of rock chops to not even worry about. They need to write and play better songs. Highly entertaining still, but I was hoping they'd evolved more. See? I can't be won over by just a pretty face!
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645944_sk6TZ-X3.jpg">
[b]B: Esben & the Witch @ Lipstick 24[/b] - I wanted to like them a lot more. I was very much in a reverb-drenched experimental mode, and there were tons of bands with that description at this SX. Esben seemed to have great potential, and not just because their lead looked like a young, hipster Jane Seymour. At times they were very entertaining, and this was when they were performing things that were more structured as actual songs. At other times, they were "WTF?!" - when their "songs" were more like graduate music school performance art pieces. Drop the latter, do more of the former, and possibly become a very good band.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646377_SmUz7-X3.jpg">
[b]B: Mount Kimbie @ Windish Agency House[/b] - I saw their name all over SXSW as they were doing like 10 sets or DJ sessions. I guess they're credited with birthing "post dubstep"?? Whatever. It's modernized early 90s thumpy club music, and it's a lot of fun. I wouldn't go out of my way to see them, but they were on before Friendly Fires and clearly knew their craft. Fun jumping around to their beats and watching all the lovely people for awhile.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646233_6fDae-X3.jpg">
[b]B: Megaphonic Thrift @ Lipstick 24[/b] - These guys have gotten a lot better since I saw them last year. I didn't know then that they were members of Casiokids and the Low Frequency In Stereo, the latter who I wanted to see more frankly. They too come with the heading of shoegaze-inspired, and there is some of that, but it's really more straight rock with some of that experimentation mixed in. Nothing great. Nothing awful.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646247_63LQz-X3.jpg">
[b]B: Cloud Nothings @ Mohawk Patio[/b] - Entertaining punky pop. Not deep at all. If you get bored with a 6-7 song festival set, you can likely kiss off liking their new full-length album. If you're hanging out and drinking on an 80deg Austin afternoon, they're perfect.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646421_ZLwsX-X3.jpg">
[b]B: No Joy @ Mohawk[/b] - 2 Girl 2 Guy lo-fi reverb-drenched shoegaze. Damn, I said lo-fi reverb-drenched shoegaze about 50 millions times during this South-By. Well here's another one. I don't think they'll ever break from the pack - not enough song-writing or truly otherworldly technical chops. Entertaining though and even fairly attractive underneath all that hair. And they really gazed at their shoes…hard!
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646227_t3Ajo-X3.jpg">
[b]B: Kitten @ Brush Square Park[/b] - Kitten's gotten a lot more musically tight than when I saw them (her) last year. The lead singer plays a lot more guitar and is more serious-minded about her singing versus just strutting around stage. She can still do that…VERY well. It's entertaining girl pop-rock, but that's about it.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646269_oFvT7-X3.jpg">
[b]B-: The Dodos @ Flamingo Cantina[/b] - Fun indie pop. Would never go out of my way to see them. Would be a good opening act for a lot of better bands - I can think of a ton worse and less-engaging bands that I've seen too much in this role. Dodos would be perfect. I realize that's not high praise, but there's nothing to damn them for.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646399_3Przq-X3.jpg">
[b]B-: Wild Flag @ The Parish[/b] - Really talented, bit older all-girl band with some good pop-rock chops and tons of energy. The MILF Formidable? Just not that into them. The band that is, not MILFs.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645865_BVDpK-X3.jpg">
[b]B-: Chappo @ Dirty Dog[/b] - These guys came on stage variably dressed like Adam Ant, a flamboyant Indian with feather arrangements, and an ornamented Poncho. First reaction – “This could blow." Upside - they ended up being pretty talented at what they do. The lead singer has a clean, high-pitched, perfectly hard-rock attuned voice - a bit of Axel Rose in him maybe. Downside - I'm not really into the sort of straight rock that they do.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646472_U45YQ-X3.jpg">
[b]B-: The Antlers @ The Parish[/b] - The presumptive "headliner" of the NPR day showcase had to come on after The Joy Formidable. Poor guys. Maybe like Buzzcocks coming on after Joy Division, the air was already out of the balloon; the adrenaline rush was crashing back down. They never stood a chance. I seem to recall they were decent enough. I also recall I left halfway thru their set.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646618_VkWjW-X3.jpg">
[b]B-: Chikita Violenta @ Mohawk[/b] - I was expecting more from what many said was the best indie rock band from Mexico. It's pretty generic indie rock. I guess maybe more of indie rock is pretty generic, and I'm just panning for quite rare gold in an increasingly tapped-out stream.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646446_BSZGZ-X3.jpg">
[b]B-: Tennis @ Club deVille[/b] - Hot girl and her dude playing Beach Boys meets Lo-Fi could be a winning or a losing prop. It's entertaining. I guess. Just didn't move me at all. Again, another entertaining-enough band when you mix in booze and 80deg weather. Someone else’s vid:
<iframe title="YouTube video player" width="640" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/MKyy5-8RamA" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
[b]C+: Bad Veins @ Skinny's Ballroom[/b] - I was expecting a lot more given the buzz about this (yet another) Ohio indie band. Maybe I was thinking I'd hear some of Pomegranates in them (who pulled out of South-By to do their own tour). Maybe I thought their reel-to-reel tape they'd use would be sorta like "Echo" from the original Bunnymen days. I don't know - it was just another indie rock permutation. Snore.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646564_6SLsm-X3.jpg">
[b]C+: Screaming Females @ Buffalo Billiards[/b] - Power trio with lead girl singer/guitarist. Hmmm, sounds like The Joy Formidable! Not really. Just kept going back to the well of the long guitar freakout solos. It didn't help that the girl sang in an Exorcists-like demon-possessed voice. Lots of technical talent. Zero charisma.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646087_wjwEx-X3.jpg">
[b]C+: An Horse @ Mohawk[/b] - These guys are whiter than Vampire Weekend. Wry sense of humor, somewhat engaging, but not doing anything really unique or special. This will be the only time I will ever say "You may just want to listen to Vampire Weekend instead."
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646643_PjXFz-X3.jpg">
[b]C+: Horse Thief @ Easy Tiger[/b] - Another lo-fi, reverb-drenched band at South-By. I think if they played some local venue apart from all the other bands doing this kinda thing, I'd have liked them a lot more. They're pretty good. They just got lost in the shuffle.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646330_P69s5-X3.jpg">
[b]C: Army Navy @ Swan Dive[/b] - I shouldn't really grade these guys. I left after two songs. Another boring, straight-laced white-boy indie pop band it seemed. Coop stuck around longer and said they were quite good. Maybe I'm in some sort of indie rock crisis. What the hell do I really like? Do I even like more than just a handful of my favorite bands? What moves me? Who am I? What am I? Am I a replicant? I don't know.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646589_cbskN-X3.jpg">
[b]C: Beach Fossiles @ Buffalo Billiards[/b] - According to Allmusic, their "reverb-slicked indie pop compares favorably to acts like Surfer Blood, Best Coast and the Drums". Zzzzzzzzz. Didn't impress enough to get me away from my quesadilla and beer in the back of the room. Only reason not a lower grade was that they were belligerent enough to yell that the venue and sound sucked and walked off temporarily in anger. Still a C though because the venue didn't suck - they did. Pic from another gig:
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646539_wNVJj-X3.jpg">
[b]C: PS I Love @ Emo's[/b] - The dreaded 2-piece band. I don't like any of them. I thought I might like Fat Guy who can do ridiculous things to a guitar. He'd probably be lovable and amazing, right? Nope. No personality and no songs. You can be Fat, Good, and Boring or Fat, Bad, and Personable but not Fat, Bad and Boring.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646129_wGJVi-X3.jpg">
[b]C: Tristen @ Mohawk[/b] - Pretty average alt-folk/alt-country. Really cute and charismatic singer not enough to elevate them any higher.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646021_H28oo-X3.jpg">
[b]C-: Ume @ Red 7[/b] - Even Ume fell victim to Red 7's consistently shit sound system. But it's more than that. Their best song is still The Conductor. Write some more and better songs…and stay away from Red 7.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226645964_X5ZKq-X3.jpg">
[b]C-: Alcoholic Faith Mission @ Hyatt[/b] - Their youtube vids are misleading. Maybe it was that it was a semi-acoustic set in a hotel. Snoozefest. Would be a D if I didn't cut them some slack over the venue. Pic from another gig:
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646667_hqPxU-X3.jpg">
[b]C-: The Republic Tigers @ Brush Square Park[/b] - Kinda straight-up midtempo rock to me. Whatever. Dammit, how long do I have to wait for TJF to come on?!
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646115_SKLCq-X3.jpg">
[b]C-: Bombay Bicycle Club @ Klub Krucial[/b] - Yeah, C- is it from me. They almost got a D, but Coop and my buddy Greg tell me they got a LOT better. WTF people?! It's after 1AM. You got to bring it with your first couple of songs, not lay a boredom egg, then decide you want to bring it later. To me, they seemed like the epitome of boring white boy indie band. They're probably better. I left after two songs. Don't go with my judgement.
<img src="http://blir.smugmug.com/photos/1226646513_XF39b-X3.jpg">
[b]D: Japanther @ Red 7 Patio[/b] - Ugh. Tiresome, by-the-numbers, testosterone-soaked punk embodying its worst stereotypes.
[b]D: Monogold @ Palm Door[/b] - Another case of a catchy lo-fi experimental shoegazey single grabbing my attention then being let down by the reality of a bar band learning to muck around with their instruments. Total bummer.
[b]D: Austra @ Red 7 Patio[/b] - Psychedelic hippy freaks pretending to be shoegazers. Cute…but awful.
[b]D: I Was Totally Destroying It @ Easy Tiger Patio[/b] - No, they weren't totally destroying it. They didn't destroy it at all. They're a local college pub band. They have a nicely packaged and hooky YouTube track, but they didn't belong here at SXSW.
[b]D: No Age @ Red 7 Patio[/b] - They're probably really a C band, but mix in Red 7's horrible PAs and you've got an easy D. I have a terrible record with 2-piece bands. None of them are really that good. Even the best of them lose my interest pretty quickly (read 'White Stripes').
[b]D: O Emperor @ Barbarella[/b] - an amalgam of everything boring about white boy indie pop...AGAIN!
[b]D: Scala & Kolachny Brothers @ Stubb's[/b] - Walked into Stubb's to see OMD. I look up and see something akin to The River Dance. Why they hell are they here? A Belgium girl's choir?? Because they're featured in The Social Network?! Because they cover Radiohead and Depeche Mode? Please fuck off.
[b]D: Scars on 45 @ Brush Square Park[/b] - Another band with a single prominent single. "Beauty's Running Wild" was featured on CSI. That's all they got. They're straight, top 40 pop. Awful. I'd never have caught these guys if I wasn't waiting for TJF.
[b]D: Ted Leo, no Pharmacists @ Mohawk Patio[/b] - You know, the dude is about 1 degree removed from the one-man band guy singing "American Pie" at your local pub. Wow, was he fucking generic.
[b]D: Unknown Mortal Orchestra @ Club deVille[/b] - They have a song called "Ffunny Ffriends" that's a pop gem. It's what will likely hook a lot of folks. Once reeled in, there won't unfortunately be much other substance there. They're quite boring live. Very nearly dreary in fact, especially the lead singer, who I recalled to be a Kiwi. They must have deported him. I think the band's mostly from Portland, and they have more of Helio Sequence in them than anything like The Shins.
[b]F: The Twilight Sad @ Maggie Mae's[/b] - Maggie's had sound problems by the time Sad came on. It frustrated them immensely, and had them acting like demented infants. Get a grip! The set sucked…bad. I'll never listen to Twilight Sad again. I realize that there's a lot of other choices for very loud, charging indie rock that are better. I'll be deleting their entire catalog from my directory. On top of all that, they've clearly been eating too much haggis and are getting fat. You can't be a slightly fat indie kid. You either have to be a rotund and charming fat guy or, conversely, malnourished.
[b]F: True Widow @ Red 7 Inside[/b] - 'Stonegaze'? Really?? It's shit. 'MBV influences'? That's bullshit. It's heinous, dreary crap. The worst band of the festival. Goodnight and thank you.