[quote][i]Originally posted by Rubellan[/i]
<br>I got home with them a couple of hours ago. As with the previous Cure remasters, the packaging and liner notes are excellent. I was IMMEDIATELY concerned when I saw this batch of remasters, along with The Glove remaster, have been done by Gary Moore. This is the guy who's been screwing up the Banshees remastering since 2002, and hasn't been involved with any of the previous Cure remasters.
I scanned all of the CD's to get a basic idea of the quality of each disc. Everything sounded pretty good, so I decided to start listening (with high quality headphones, as I do with most of my CD's) to The Top CD. Everything sounded surprisingly good. No inappropriate fades, no channel fluctions. Everything was very satisfying...THEN, the song 'Bananafishbones' started, and I immediately noticed it sounded considerably faster. I pulled out my original CD to make sure I wasn't having some sort of seizure. The original CD sounded fine, so I checked the time on the song. The original CD clocks in at 3:10, the new CD clocks in at 3:00. To cut 10 full seconds out of a song, the tape had to be speeded up considerably. How frustrating! Now the album heads towards the end with a guest appearance by a slightly barritone appearance from The Chipmunks.
The speed returns to normal for the final song on the CD, which makes me wonder if it was more Gary Moore hack work, or if Robert Smith decided to tinker with the song during mastering.
This is the only CD I have listened to so far. I will say the bonus disc for The Glove CD sounds really interesting from the bits I've heard.
[/quote]
Interesting.. I listened to The Top in the car on my drive home today, and I did notice that Bananafishbones sounded really different, but I couldn't put my finger on why. I will definitely compare the two. I can only guess that Robert wanted to make the change; i would imagine that such a substantive change wouldn't have been done without his prompting.
---
www.BluespaceRadio.com
New Wave and beyond... music without boundaries.