by fiftypercent » Wed Nov 29, 2006 4:28 am
It probably sounds simplistic, but if the series is only going to sell so many units, then in order to break even the price is going to have to go up. Personally, I place a much higher premium on rare stuff I can't find than, say, on buying the latest Elton John or Meat Loaf CD. If I can pay $12-$15 for that, I would pay double for a rarities disc. And more if my selections were front and center!
The reason I like the RA series, and others, is that (a) I want an official shiny non-bootleg CD with cool stuff on it (b) I'm sorry but even an mp3 ripped at the highest rate possible is no substitute for an official "collectible" product (c) I like the fact that kudos is going to artists who weren't in fashion even the first time around and keeps their music alive (d) I also like that we fans get to have a say on what we want - imagine if the Now series was produced that way.
To weigh in on the discussion about extended mixes or single mixes, I would say this: in all honesty, a lot of 12" mixes were kind of crap, even if they are rare. A lot of great hard to find artists didn't even produce a 12" mix, let alone one that beats out the 7" mix every time. But collectibility is a big part of the selling point. I would also say it's probably easier for a group of fans to come to a consensus on great 12" mixes to include, because the field is so much smaller. I think if everyone selected 15 single tracks to include on a compilation, there would be very little overlap. I'm also wondering if licensing some of these more obscure 7" records might be a nightmare too.
Perhaps the solution would be this: straw poll fifty or so contributors to the forum giving the top 50 single tracks they would like to see on a disc. Tabulate all the results and look into the licensing issues for the top 25-30. Go with 15 that are easiest to license. If nothing else, go with the artists that are popular even if different tracks are suggested. Call the CD something different and go the Marillion route and have fans like us pre-order the disc at a fair price (say $25) to put towards costs. I'm sorry but I think it's unlikely that the kid on the street is going to jump up and down to buy something that has Troy Tate, Kevin Kitchen or Secession on it. It's up to us, guys.