The one on party Party Soundtrack is the original verison (5:50), the one on the gift and every other comp (5:39 or 5:43) is the re-record that first appeared on the if I was 12"
Posted: Thu Oct 14, 2010 9:54 am
by 1980-F
From where do you have the information, that the song was re-recorded?
I've never spotted any difference between the version on the Party Party Soundtrack and the one on the Gift CD except of a slightly longer fade.
Cheers
1980-F
Posted: Thu Oct 14, 2010 3:55 pm
by Andee1970
I read it on some Midge Ure discography site, yes it is longer and a re-record. But does anyone have it.
Posted: Fri Oct 15, 2010 8:17 am
by clarence
I've got the version from the Party Party CD and it clocks in at 5:43. Perhaps they used different versions on the vinyl and CD issues.
Well, the version clarence posted is identical to the one on the 'If I Was' 12inch and the 'Gift' remasters (I have all of these!)
(So according to the board policy this should be removed as it is still commercially available.)
I also checked my 'Party Party' Vinyl and a MP3 rip I found on the net some time ago and I must admit: Andee, you're right - the version on the original Party Party OST is different!!!
But I'm not sure, if the newer one is really a re-recording or just a remix. On the newer version of "Man Who Sold The World" the piano sound is much more prominent in the mix, the drums sound a little more "crisp" (though still the same computer sounds), the vocals (especially the whispers) are mixed a bit different and it has a different fade out. Everything else seems identical for my ears.
I will post the older version later - no time right now.
@clarence:
Do you own the Party Party CD? Or do you just have an MP3 version from the net?
I have also have a complete MP3 rip of the soundtrack, but I'm not sure if it is really from CD or just a good vinyl remaster. Mine includes the original version of MWSTW, though.
Cheers
1980-F
Posted: Thu Oct 28, 2010 3:34 pm
by clarence
i only have the tracks i liked from it. we used to stock it at the import distributor i used to work for and they used to let us borrow & burn whatever we wanted to deter anyone from stealing.
Re: RQ: man Who Sold The World - Midge Ure
Posted: Sat Apr 02, 2016 1:14 pm
by negative1
well, another soundtrack to buy now for the track..