by rewind » Tue Oct 12, 2004 5:41 am
Torchomatic was a cool site, as is yours, ekahob. But let's not lose site of the fact that posting songs for download (without permission) is ILLEGAL. It doesn't matter if the record is available or not. By giving away a song for free, you hurt the WRITER/ARTIST who may have otherwise had an oppurtunity to gain some financial retribution for his work, minimal though that payment may have been.
Here in the U.S., the "powers that be" is mostly the RIAA. They represent the interests of record labels, which, your right, have been out to lunch and probably have no interest in ever releasing some of this music. However, by giving the song away for free we devalue that work, decreasing the possibilty that the artist may be able to release it again through a re-issue label, perhaps. Nobody wants to invest in a song that has already been available for free.
As admirable and well-intentioned as our efforts are, "keeping the flame alive" is not justification enough for illegally posting songs for free. Think of the struggling artist whose only income may be from the royalties accrued from that one-hit wonder that keeps showing up on (potential) compilations!
Ideally, those selfish record labels should loosen up their ownership over titles they will never care about, and give the artists or re-issue companies greater leeway in releasing them.