by geoffolehane » Mon Oct 24, 2011 10:57 am
This is my first posting to NW Outpost in several years.
I read this entire thread and found it to be incredibly insightful and interesting. There is much truth is what everyone has said. I think Seona85 hit on a number of viable points.
I suppose I could answer the question of why New Wave died with one word - Madonna.
Here is someone who took all the fun elements of New Wave like the catchy songs, dance beats, sexual innuendo, and lavish clothing (or lack thereof) and capitalized on it to become the darling of MTV, which in those days was about the best promotion a musical act could get. Her outlandish behavior (by 1980's standards) made news headlines, which resulted in more record sales. Think about it. Madonna rose to prominence about 1983 and was not long after that that New Wave started to slide.
Another nail in the coffin related to the musicians themselves. Many musicians put out these fabulous, inventive, off-the cuff, debut albums. Suddenly they were getting airplay and their records were beginning to sell. Sometimes they would follow it up with a halfway decent second album. But then they began to take themselves too serious. What started out as fun became a job with deadlines to meet, tours to take, and a business to run. I think it showed in their output.
Eventually the commercial radio stations picked out a few gems with their roots in New Wave such as the Police, Tears for Fears, the Cars, and U2 and started playing their music all the time essentially ignorning all the obscure acts that were still putting out some creative inventive stuff. Most of the classic New Wave acts (that stayed together) who had hits after about 1985 were sounding more mainstream. Compare OMD in 1981 to OMD in 1986 or the B-52's from 1980 to 1986. I reaffirm that it had become a job for them.
And a few people have mentioned Stock-Aitken-Waterman and I have to say there is definitely some truth to that. By 1988 I was buying albums by Kylie Minogue and thinking she was the greatest new pop act in the world. There is also something to be said about highly-produced electronic dance music of the day. By 1986 I was heavily into the Pet Shop Boys.
But I don't think New Wave really died. I think it evolved. The term "New Wave" became passe. I worked in radio broadcasting in the 1980's and around 1987 Radio & Records, which was the industry's number one trade magazine, had added a "Modern Rock" section including the Top 30 every week based on airplay. Radio stations all iver the US would send them their playlists and from that these Top 30 lists were developed. I have to think that most non-metro radio stations were influenced by that. If they saw a song on the "Modern Rock" charts, their tunnel vision attitudes about music would tell them that it was not a commercial success. So they'd ignore it and turn to the Popular Music, Album Rock, or Adult Contemporary sections.
But I think what started as New Wave in the 80's has led to modern day alternative rock and techno and I think that's a good thing.