by coop41 » Mon Sep 17, 2007 9:13 am
[quote][i]Originally posted by brock[/i]
<br>I'm going to have to disagree with some of your points.[quote][i]Originally posted by shovelbum[/i]
<br>Reasons to NOT shop at Walmart:
The money goes to the owners of the walmart Corporation.[/quote]
The owners of Wal-Mart (ie shareholders) are you, me and everyone else with an index fund. Or did you mean only the Walton family?<br>[quote]Walmart very rarely hires full time employees[/quote]No different than mom & pop stores which compete for my $$.
[quote]Also, The $$$ they save by importing items from China not only puts out mom and pop, it also puts out any other local and/or nation-wide labor. Those people end up on welfare. Who's paying for welfare? YOU AND I. This causes a depression in the economy, which causes inflation, which causes you and I to pay in more ways than just the check-out stand at Walmart.[/quote]Does a depression cause inflation? I know the economy is generally cyclical, but I guess I need to brush-up on my economics.
I think some of the local Wal-Mart employees would be on welfare if it weren't for their job.
[quote]Of the profits made by the owners of Walmart, a portion goes to lobbyists and other politicians pockets in an effort to get the govt. (so far almost always successfully) to help the owners to pay less taxes, etc[/quote]
I think this is true of many industries. Wal-Mart's just another player, albeit a big player.
[quote]
Shop there if it makes you happy, but just know that the $$$ you save is soaked in misery and probably costing you more than you realize in the long run.[/quote]The few $$ that I save stay in my non-interest bearing checking account (maybe [i]soaked in misery[/i] is a good description) until the next round of bills (mortgage, child care, utilities, credit card, HELOC, etc.) arrive. Then in April I usually write two checks when taxes are due. If my taxes pay for health insurance for others, so be it. My taxes also pay for police, fire, my kids' education, roads, etc. If Wal-Mart gets a subsidy from me, then they've played the game well. At the end of the day, I guess I really don't care...until the next tax increase.
[/quote]
[/quote]
I have to agree.
In addition, while shovelbum states some valid points, some are also outdated, incorrect or slanted to make a point (A political one no doubt). I suppose I could make the point that Wal Mart pay averages [i]twice[/i] the minimum wage, and while true, paints no more clear picture than the above "horror story". I'm also guessing that they create a couple more jobs than "Mom and Pop" (don't they only hire relatives anyway?). Also, are there really that many "Mom and Pop" grocery stores (or clothing stores or office supply stores or paint stores or CD stores) out there? (What? You can get all that in [i]One[/i] place AND at the lowest price?) Or is it more likely Wal Mart is competing with unionized grocery store chains who pay inflated wages and pass along the higher prices to the consumer and are probably guilty of many of the same sins as Wal Mart (or many other large companies)? I'd reckon to say that Americans speak with their wallets, and judging by the success of Wal Mart, most of the bashing is political fluff.
Eight 6 had probably the best response.