by fiftypercent » Tue Apr 28, 2009 6:13 am
[quote][i]Originally posted by SomebodySomewhere[/i]
<br>Did fiftypercent remove a post that I missed? Or was it just upset that fiftypercent ignored its email?
Here's a tip to it. If you want something in the future, try contacting the actual band members. I'm pretty sure they'd have copies of their own record, since they, you know, made it. Like, what, the band thought the record was so bad, they destroyed all evidence?
[/quote]
Yes, I did modify and delete a couple of posts. What happened was that a link appeared out of the blue to an auction on eBay. I was a little surprised. Another person made a comment and I jumped on that because I had no idea how someone would be able to obtain two perfect condition singles based on my limited information, so quickly. I did not specifically say there was something wrong with the item being auctioned, but I urged people to be careful considering the list price was $99.99 minimum bid.
I also felt that there are other places to post links to auctions so it seemed like blatant profiteering to me. Once I had more information that proved the item was genuine, I thought it was only proper to withdraw my earlier comments.
In his defence, erucsbo has every right to sell an item he obtained through his own efforts for whatever value a buyer places on it. I have bought and sold many items on eBay over the years, sometimes making a good profit. There is nothing wrong with an entrepreneurial spirit. I'm not sure that this forum or this topic is the appropriate place to discuss other auctions that may have taken place. I want this topic to be about celebrating the music of Seeing Red and discussing the band. But if your first post is to provide a link to an auction and not to add anything new to the discussion, you should expect some heat from other NWO members. That's why Marie3 is on point with one thing - if an item is sold at auction only because of the NWO and the passion of its members, why shouldn't the owner of the forum (MikeP) feel like he has facilitated this sale? Aren't finder's fees valid when it comes to music?
To me, the mp3/usb/ripping issue is not really relevant. This person is not under any obligation to me or the forum to do that. In fact, I understand that for some collectors, playing the record even once is a no-no because of the needle wear.
But, what I would like to see is some accommodation down the line. I'm trying to find more copies of this record, and like I said I hope the ex-band members have one or the master tape so they can get a good digital product to sell. My fear is that these guys were probably in their late teens and recorded one cheap session, so I'm not optimistic that they would have archived this properly. More information from erucsbo would help me to think about where to look. And, if it turned out he had the best copy left in existence, I would like to think he would be willing to work with me to help the band out. And that is really all there is to discuss.